Act 1 troubleshooting · Verified 22 November 2026
Why did I get the bad ending in Kingdom of Marionettes?
In Act 1, a regular total of 2 affection points or fewer gives the bad ending; 3 or more reaches the good ending; Jestyn's collar choice needs 4 or more. Creator-confirmed · Act 1 These numbers come from Thepipi's ending guide; the Crownus secret ending uses a separate name-entry condition.
Check the four scored decisions
The creator assigns points to the farmers, land purchase, Jestyn's criticism and chocolate decisions in Act 1. Creator-confirmed · Act 1 Add one value from each row before checking the ending or collar threshold.
| Decision | Answer and value |
|---|---|
| Farmers | Money, water channels or seeds +2; ask for time 0; leave the problem to them −1. |
| Land purchase | Refuse +1; delay 0; agree −1. |
| Jestyn's criticism | Find it funny +2; find it annoying 0. |
| Chocolate | Decline 0; eat −1. |
I helped the farmers. Why did I still get the bad ending?
Helping the farmers gives +2, which is one point short of the 3-point regular good-ending threshold. Creator-confirmed · Act 1 If you then agree to buy the land (−1), find Jestyn's criticism annoying (0) and decline the chocolate (0), the final total is 1, so the bad ending follows the published rule.
Change only the land decision from agreement (−1) to refusal (+1) in that example and the total rises from 1 to 3. Eating the chocolate would instead subtract another point. Use the point planner to check your exact four answers.
Why is the collar choice missing?
The regular good ending starts at 3 points, but the collar scene option requires at least 4. Creator-confirmed · Act 1 Farmer aid (+2), land refusal (+1), an annoyed response (0) and no chocolate (0) total 3: good ending, collar requirement unmet.
For an exact 4-point route, help the farmers (+2), delay the land purchase (0), find Jestyn's criticism funny (+2) and decline the chocolate (0). The creator describes the collar as a scene choice; this page does not assert that every build renders a failed choice as a grey button.
Why did the Crownus secret ending not trigger?
The creator's Act 1 secret instruction is to inspect the writing on the King puppet's door, then enter crownus when Jestyn asks for your name. Creator-confirmed · Act 1 A high affection total does not replace that named sequence; another puppet name may change dialogue without locking the same ending.
Check the clue, the exact name and the timing of the name prompt. The Crownus guide covers the sequence separately from the four affection-point decisions.
Can later choices recover from dismissing the farmers?
Leaving the farmers to solve the drought gives −1, and the largest remaining gains are land refusal (+1), finding Jestyn's criticism funny (+2) and declining the chocolate (0). Arithmetic from creator-confirmed values The maximum final total is therefore 2, below the regular good-ending threshold of 3.
Why do these points fail in Act 2?
The creator's 3-point good-ending and 4-point collar rules are for Act 1. Creator-confirmed scope The independent Day 2 study instead reports 5 Crownus secret points for Truth and 3 Prieston route points for Prieston; these are player-tested route findings, not an official Act 2 point chart.
If you reached Day 2 but keep looping, use the Act 2 common mistakes checklist. The Act 1 vs Act 2 comparison lists the separate triggers side by side.
Evidence: Thepipi's 27 February 2026 Act 1 ending guide gives the choice values, 3-point good ending, 2-or-fewer bad ending, 4-point collar gate and Crownus name instruction. ADVaNCE VN and MysteryCorgi's Day 2 route study is the separate source for the player-tested Truth and Prieston values. Sources rechecked 22 November 2026.